Anirudh RegidiJul 09, 2021 12:40:17 IST
External GPU boxes have been around for a while now, but barring a brief surge in popularity 3-4 years ago, they’ve mostly died down.
A traditional eGPU involves a full-size desktop-class GPU placed in an enclosure and connected to a laptop or PC (in some cases) via a Thunderbolt 3 interface. On paper, this is great, but the performance penalty is severe.
A GPU normally connects to your PC via an interface called PCIe, and it needs 16 PCIe data l anes to perform at its best. Depending on the GPU you’re using, 8 lanes will also do, with the performance hit on medium to high-end GPUs being limited to a few percentage points.
The Thunderbolt interface used by eGPUs, on the other hand, only offers 4x PCIe lanes at best, and half that number if your eGPU is driving your laptop’s internal display.
While you could never get desktop-class performance from these enclosures, they seemed like a great way to augment your existing laptop’s performance.
Personally, I was never a fan of this design. Sure, you could transform your Ultrabook into a gaming notebook, but eGPUs are expensive, aren’t portable, and are clunky to set up. If I must dedicate a permanent space for a chunky eGPU box and external monitor, pay a premium for the enclosure and desktop-class GPU, and be prepared to compromise on performance, why wouldn’t I just buy a slightly larger, more powerful gaming laptop? Or better yet, why not build a PC?
With the ROG XG Mobile, Asus has attempted to address these issues, and I think Asus has succeeded, after a fashion.
What is XG Mobile?
Unlike most eGPU options, XG Mobile is a self-contained eGPU and USB hub combo that houses either an RTX 3070 or RTX 3080 GPU. The catch is that these are the mobile variants of the 3070 and 3080 and are not user-replaceable. The 3080 can operate at up to 150 W while the 3070 can operate between 125 W and 140 W depending on thermal headroom.
Using a mobile GPU allows Asus to trim enough fat to deliver an eGPU that’s about as thick as a laptop power brick and perhaps three times as wide. It’s still large, but now it’s small enough (and light enough) to toss into a bag.
Another change is the interface, which uses a proprietary Asus connector — found only on the ROG Flow X13 laptop for now — to deliver 8x PCIe 3.0 lanes to the eGPU, eliminating the biggest bottleneck.
Additionally, you get a bunch of I/O on the eGPU box, including: HDMI 2.0b, DP1.4 with G-Sync, RJ45 LAN, 4x USB 3.2 Gen 1 Type-A, and an SD card reader rated at UHS-II speeds.
The dock comes with its own 280 W power brick that’s sufficient for the RTX 3080 (in my review unit) as well as the Flow X13 laptop. A dedicated fan keeps the GPU cool.
Performance: Is it worth it?
I tested the XG Mobile and Flow X13 laptop combo in 3 modes:
- Flow X13 with internal GPU (GTX 1650 Max-Q)
- Flow X13 + XG Mobile driving the internal display
- Flow X13 + XG Mobile driving an external display
As can be seen from the charts below, the performance uplift is huge. We’re looking at 2-3x the performance in games and a 10-15x performance improvement in tasks like 3D rendering, and this is when driving the internal display. When powering an external display, performance improves by about 10 percent on average. Interestingly, video transcoding via the internal GPU was faster than when using the more powerful external one. My guess is that the additional processing overhead sapped some performance from the system in this task.
Based on these numbers alone, the XG Mobile seems like it’s worth it. You get to carry a featherweight Ultrabook for light work, and when you want to game, you whip out the tiny XG Mobile unit and plug it in. Win-win, right? Maybe.
Verdict: It’s priced high, but I think it’s still worth it
There are two variants of the XG Mobile, and they’re priced as follows:
- XG Mobile GC31R: RTX 3070 8 GB – Rs 69,990
- XG Mobile GC31S: RTX 3080 16 GB – Rs 1,39,990
I haven’t tested the 3070-powered variant of the XG Mobile, but from my experience testing laptops equipped with the 3070 and 3080, I can tell you right now that there’s no way the 3080 is twice as good as the 3070. At a high, I’d expect the performance difference between the two to top out at 20 percent. If you’re buying, ignore the 3080 model.
If you’re someone looking for exactly the kind of experience the Flow X13 + XG Mobile combo offers, I think it’s worth it. Personally, I’d rather just spend Rs 1.4 lakhs on the bulkier Zephyrus G15 than deal with the hassle of an eGPU dock and requisite desk setup, but that’s just me.
As far as eGPU solutions go, I think Asus’ XG Mobile is one of the simpler, no-compromises, gamer-focused designs out there.
I like what Asus is doing here, and while I’m still not a fan of eGPUs in general, I can respect the design and engineering effort that went into creating a system like XG Mobile, and I hope to see more such designs in the future.
Note: XG Mobile is currently compatible with the Flow X13 laptop only. Asus tells me that they’re looking into expanding support for the interface in the near future.